KRONOS Vol. I, Issue 1
PHOBIA, AMNESIA, AND THE PSYCHE
by LEWIS M. GREENBERG
"It is a psychological phenomenon in the life of individuals as well as whole nations that the
most terrifying events of the past may be forgotten or displaced into the subconscious mind. As if
obliterated are impressions that should be unforgettable. To uncover their vestiges and their distorted
equivalents in the physical life of peoples is a task not unlike that of overcoming amnesia in a single
Immanuel Velikovsky, Worlds in Collision (1950)
"There never can be a man so lost as one who is lost in the vast and intricate corridors of his
own lonely mind, where none may reach and none may save. There never was a man so helpless as
one who cannot remember." -
Isaac Asimov, Pebble in the Sky (1950)
The concept of "A Collective Amnesia" was first propounded as a serious working hypothesis
in Worlds in Collision.(1) It was conceived in an effort to reasonably explain Mankind's inability to
consciously remember its catastrophic experiences resulting from the Earth's participation in a series
of disastrous cosmic perturbations.
The subject of a collective amnesia is still a basically unexplored area of psychology requiring
penetrating research far beyond the immediate scope of the present paper. The following essay is
therefore primarily intended as a fascinating and provocative case study of two fictional accounts
involving psychological trauma and the principle of collective amnesia. The material offered here has
been gleaned from the writings of Isaac Asimov, a masterful science-fiction author and often harsh
critic of Immanuel Velikovsky.
Pebble in the Sky(2)
"Grow old along with me!
The best is yet to be,
The last of life, for which the first was made. . ."
With these words of Robert Browning running through his mind and the quietude of old age
upon him, sixty-two year old Joseph Schwartz is suddenly propelled, via a quirk of nuclear physics,
from the streets of Chicago tens of thousands of years into the future.
When next he comes to his senses, Schwartz finds himself on an Earth far removed from the
Chicago of 1949 though he does not know it. The unrecognizable surroundings cause Schwartz to
doubt his sanity. He is psychologically disoriented and wanders in search of familiarity.
After encountering some strangers, Schwartz is taken to the city of Chica for supposed
therapeutic treatment. Once there, he is still unable to regain his mental equilibrium. "Was his trouble
amnesia, then? Were they treating him for that? Was all this world normal and natural, while the world he thought he remembered was only the fantasy of an amnesic brain? . . . Had he
once been a mathematician, in the days before his amnesia? (p. 52)"
With great effort, Schwartz embarks upon his quest for the answer to his dilemma.
Persistence and tenacity enable him to learn that he is, in fact, millennia in the future. But, the
overwhelming thought causes panic and vacillation and in a defensive reflex he feels "himself
shrinking back to amnesia. (p. 102)" (emphasis added) An introspective moment temporarily
convinces him that he was not an amnesiac but [indeed] "a man who had stumbled through time. (p.
106)" Nevertheless, doubt reasserts itself and the time-slip theory fades "in his mind; amnesia again.
He was a criminal, perhaps - a dangerous man, who must be watched. Maybe he had once been a
high official who could not be simply killed but must be tried. Perhaps his amnesia was the method
used by his unconscious to escape the realization of some tremendous guilt. (p. 107)" (emphasis
Schwartz's individual plight, however, is nothing compared to the surrounding general state
of affairs. He has emerged in a world oblivious of its past (except for an elite few) set amidst an
inhabited universe which finds an earthly source for its population to be an incredible notion. Somewhere, in the remoteness of time, Mankind has undergone an experience which wiped out and
obscured the very memory of its terrestrial origin. Mother Earth has become its own unwanted step-child.
A sprawling Galactic Empire peopled with trillions of souls has reduced the Earth's status to
a mere "pebble in the sky," a "pigpen of a world" covered with uninhabitable sectors of radioactivity.
Moreover, orthodox archaeology holds that Human types have evolved independently on various
planets and that the Earth is nought but a "brutish peasant world" and "the least significant planet of
In the extreme minority is a small group of "mystics" and a lone archaeologist named
Arvardan who believe "that Humanity originated upon some single planet and had radiated by degrees
throughout the Galaxy. (p. 25)" Eventually, after much trial and tribulation, the intersecting paths
of Schwartz and Arvardan converge and the truth of the matter is revealed. Earth is indeed the
planetary source of universal Humankind but somewhere along the aeons this fact was forgotten. A
hint of what might have happened is given by Schwartz when asked about his own time period
"We had an atomic bomb. Uranium - and plutonium - I guess that's what made this world
radioactive. There must have been another war after all - after I left . . . Atomic bombs. (p. 144) "
The implication is obvious. The devastation and horror of yet another World War – this time nuclear
– has not only transformed the Earth into a radio-active hulk but somehow caused the terrestrial
survivors as well as the interstellar colonists to forget their own cultural and genetic heritage.
Since Earth is the one inhabited radioactive world (p. 28) in the entire Galaxy, its uniqueness
can only be construed as strong evidence for its martial guilt; and though this latter point is not
elaborated upon nor even explicitly mentioned, one is tempted to read into it the psychological reason
why an earthly origin was forgotten and the planet held in such complete disdain. (1)
Interestingly, certain earthly place names are retained in altered form Chica (Chicago),
Washenn (Washington), Senloo (St. Louis) while the correct name for each of the various planets
is remembered! (p. 101) Yet, the very terrestrial origin of man is considered to be an outlandish
thought. Only the Society of Ancients - a terrestrial organization - believes that "Earth was at one
time the sole home of Humanity" and will be again. (p. 55) In an attempt to make its own prediction
come true, the Society of Ancients strives to decimate the entire universal population through
bacterial warfare. The blatant act of vengeance is thwarted by Schwartz, however, who fulfills his
time-warped destiny and emerges as the ultimate descendant of the archetypal hero.
"If the stars should appear one night in a thousand years, how would men believe and adore,
and preserve for many generations the remembrance of the city of God?"
Taking the above words of Emerson as an inspirational point of departure, Isaac Asimov
deftly weaves a chilling tale of the planet Lagash. Lighted by six suns, its history of civilization
displays an ominous cyclic character shrouded in mystery.
Various successive cultures have been consumed by fire at the apex of their greatness without
a hint as to the cause; not a shred of concrete evidence has ever been left behind to account for the
past conflagrations; neither a meaningful recollection nor a legacy of remembrance. Only the
esoteric "myth of the Stars" contained in the Book of Revelations belonging to a group known as the
Cultists offers a puzzling but ridiculed clue. ". . . Every two thousand and fifty years Lagash entered
a huge cave, so that all the suns disappeared, and there came total darkness all over the world! And
then . . . things called Stars appeared, which robbed men of their souls and left them unreasoning
brutes, so that they destroyed the civilization they themselves had built up. (p. 9)"
The deadly riddle seems to have no answer until, almost by accident, the secret of Lagash's
recurring disasters fatefully unfolds step by step towards a climactic disclosure. It all starts when
several astronomers apply themselves to the Theory of Universal Gravitation. They discover, much
to their chagrin, that the motions of Lagash about its primary sun - Alpha - and the orbit observed
cannot be accounted for by standard gravitational computations and known perturbation factors.
Years pass as theory upon theory fails to solve the enigma. At last, with no other recourse, the head
of the Cultists is called in for consultation and provides some informative assistance. The meeting
of science and theology produces a new line of scientific reasoning and an unanticipated and
shattering postulation - A nonluminous planetary body akin to Lagash and rotating around it could
also exist yet be invisible amidst the eternal blaze of sunlight. This satellite would not only account
for the deviations of Lagash's theoretical orbit but would eventually get in the way of a sun.
Calculations are quickly made which indicate "that the eclipse Will occur only when the
arrangement of the suns is such that Beta [one of the suns] is alone in its hemisphere and at maximum
distance. The eclipse that results, with the moon seven times the apparent diameter of Beta, covers
all of Lagash and lasts well over half a day, so that no spot on the planet escapes the effects. That
eclipse comes once every two thousand and forty-nine years. (p. 11 ) "
A reporter named Theremon learns of this unusual phenomenon during an interview with
Sheerin, a psychologist attached to a group of astronomers very much concerned with the entire
matter. Within the confines of a fortress-like Observatory, these scientists anxiously await the
occultation of Beta. Much trepidation, excitement, and tension permeates the air. As it happens, the
moment of eclipse is once again rapidly approaching upon Lagash and the astronomers are feverishly
preparing to photograph the unknown. In the meantime, many people have been sent to a place of
refuge called the Hideout along with certain records for the future.
Sheerin explains to the visiting Theremon the basic reason for the present apprehension of his
colleagues and himself. "There is a psychological term for mankind's instinctive fear of the absence
of light. We call it 'claustrophobia,' because the lack of light is always tied up with enclosed places,
so that fear of one is fear of the other ... Imagine Darkness - everywhere. No light, as far as you can
see. The houses, the trees, the fields, the earth, the sky - black! And Stars thrown in, for all I know -
whatever they are. Can you conceive it? . . . You can't conceive that. Your brain wasn't built for the
conception any more than it was built for the conception of infinity or of eternity. You can only talk
about it. A fraction of the reality upsets you, and when the real thing comes, your brain is going to
be presented with the phenomenon outside its limits of comprehension. You will go mad, completely
and permanently! (pp. 14-15)"
Theremon apparently fails to grasp the full import of Sheerin's statement and the point has to
be angrily driven home. "If you were in Darkness, what would you want more than anything else;
what would it be that every instinct would call for? Light, damn you, light! . . . And how would you
get light? . . . You burn something . . . It gives off light and people know that . . . and wood isn't
handy - so they'll burn whatever is nearest. They'll have their light - and every center habitation goes
up in flames! (pp. 15-16)"
The conversation is abruptly ended as a series of incidents stirs the Observatory. An intruder
Cultist - Latimer 25 - is seized before he can lay damaging hands on the astro-cameras. He accuses
Aton, the head of the Observatory, of undermining religious faith by presenting scientific backing for
Cultist beliefs. "You made of the Darkness and of the Stars a natural phenomenon and removed all
its real significance. That was blasphemy." The altercation is cut short as Beta begins to shrink before
the encroaching blackness and the unnerved scientists struggle frantically to maintain their composure
in order to take pictures of the eclipse.
Latimer commences to intone from the Book of Revelations (p. 23) first in the present and
then in an old-cycle tongue. Verse after verse signals a portent of doom. Theremon wonders how
the Cultists "manage to keep the Book of Revelations going from cycle to cycle, and how on Lagash
did it get written in the first place?" Sheerin replies that the method of passing on the Book of
Revelations is unimportant since "the book can't help but be a mass of distortion, even if it is based
on fact. Naturally, the book was based, in the first place, on the testimony those least qualified to
serve as historians; that is children and morons; and was probably edited and re-edited through the
cycles. (p. 25)"
At this point, an associate of Sheerin, Beenay, interjects his own ideas about what the Stars
might be. He suggests the existence of other suns so distant that "they'd appear small, like so many
marbles" once "there'd be no real sunlight to drown them out . . of course the Cultists talk of millions
of Stars, but that's probably exaggeration. There just isn't place in the universe you could put a
million suns - unless they touch one another. (p. 29)"
Outside the Observatory, Beta continues to disappear within the enveloping Darkness. Slowly
but surely the last light of Lagash dwindles. Panic ensues. Egged on by the trauma of the eclipse and
the uncontrollable zeal of the Cultists, the citizens of Lagash storm the Observatory in desperation.
Within the Observatory, the scientists have barred the doors and lit some torches. The
cameras are manned. Then, without warning, Latimer makes one final bid to impede the
photographing and is blocked by Theremon who wrestles him to the floor. Suddenly, the last rays
of sunlight are cut off; a choking gasp is heard from Beenay, an hysterical giggle from Sheerin;
beneath Theremon, Latimer's body goes limp as his eyes recede into blankness and a bubble of froth
forms upon his lips.
"With the slow fascination of fear," Theremon struggles to raise himself and turns "his eyes
toward the blood-curdling blackness of the window. Through it shone the Stars! Not Earth's feeble
thirty-six hundred Stars visible to the eye; Lagash was in the center of a giant cluster. Thirty
thousand mighty suns shone down in a soul-searing splendor that was more frighteningly cold in its
awful indifference than the bitter wind that shivered across the cold, horribly bleak world. (p. 35)"
Theremon staggers "to his feet, his throat constricting him to breathlessness, all the muscles
of his body writhing in an intensity of terror and sheer fear beyond bearing. He was going mad and
knew it, and somewhere deep inside a bit of sanity was screaming, struggling to fight off the hopeless
flood of black terror . . . 'Light!' he screamed." (p. 35)
Elsewhere in the confines of the Observatory, a babbling and incoherent Aton whimpers
"horribly like a terribly frightened child. 'Stars - all the Stars - we didn't know at all. We didn't know
anything. We thought six stars in a universe is something the Stars didn't notice is Darkness forever
and ever and ever and the walls are breaking in and we didn't know we couldn't know and anything'
–" (pp. 35-36)
As Aton's pitiful soliloquy runs its course, a torch is overturned and extinguished. "In the
instant, the awful splendor of the indifferent Stars leaped nearer to them."
"On the horizon outside the window, in the direction of Saro City, a crimson glow
began growing, strengthening in brightness, that was not the glow of a sun.
The long night had come again."
1. I. Velikovsky, Worlds in Collision
(Doubleday: Garden City, N. Y,, 1950), pp. 298-311 and 383.
2. I. Asimov, Pebble in the Sky
(Fawcett Crest paperback ed. of Doubleday hardcover: N.Y., 1950).
3. Cf. A. Clarke, "If I Forget Thee, Oh Earth . . . . in The Nine Billion Names of God
(Harbrace Paperbound Library: N. Y., 1967), pp. 235-240: also A. Clarke, Against the Fall
of Night (Gnome Press: N. Y., 1953) and rewritten as The City and the Stars (N. Y.,
1956). Obviously conjectural liberties are being exercised here in the extreme since
motivational analysis is being applied to a purely fictional situation. The realistic plausibility
of events does allow extrapolation into reality, however, thereby lending considerable
justification for the analysis.
4. I. Asimov, "Nightfall," first appearance in Astounding Science Fiction,
Sept. 1941; also in Nightfall and other Stories by Asimov (Doubleday: Garden City, 1969), pp. 2-36.
"Nightfall" was chosen as the #1 science-fiction short story of all time by the Science Fiction
Writers of America - see The Science Fiction Hall of Fame
Vol. 1, (Doubleday: Garden City, 1970), ed. Robert Silverberg, p. x.